Armerys (@Armerys)

__The Trinity Early Consensus:__ __Apostolic Era:__ The early church baptized in the name of the Father, Son, and Spirit (Matt 28:19) and worshipped Jesus as Lord (Phil 2:11) while maintaining Jewish monotheism. __Pre-Nicene Fathers:__ Writers like Ignatius, Justin Martyr, and Irenaeus (1st and 2nd centuries) consistently affirmed the Deity of Christ and the Spirit. The terminology evolved (e.g., trias, homoousios) to defend against heresies, but the core belief was present from the start. It was a clarification of existing apostolic faith, not an addition. __Transubstantiation Late Innovation:__ __Diversity of View:__ For the first millennium, the Church held a "mystery" view of the Eucharist. Pope Gelasius I (5th century) explicitly taught that the "substance of bread and wine does not cease." __Medieval Definition:__ The specific dogma of Transubstantiation (substance changes, accidents remain) was not defined until the Fourth Lateran Council (1215) and solidified at Trent (1551). __Accretion Defined:__ Unlike the Trinity, which explains biblical data, Transubstantiation adds a philosophical mechanism --Aristotelian metaphysics-- that: * Were unknown for the direct receivers of the message ( 1st-century Jews) * Imposes a literalism that creates logical conflicts with Scripture --the blood prohibition * Contradicts earlier papal teaching It is a true accretion—a layer added centuries after the Apostles that alters the original simplicity of the ordinance. #Transubstantiation #Eucharist #Trinity #CatholicChurch #OrthodoxChurch #Tradition #Magisterium #Scripture #SolaScriptura