Posted

0 replies · 0 reposts · 0 likes

# SERIES: FROM COUNTERFEIT LIGHT TO CHRIST ## ROSARIO CHAMPAGNE BUTTERFIELD — EPISODE 22, PART 6: CHRISTIAN DISCERNMENT AND RESPONSE *(Gab Pro Edition)* --- ## 📖 EPISODE CONTEXT Rosario Champagne Butterfield was a tenured professor of Queer Theory at Syracuse University, a committed lesbian activist, and a fierce opponent of Christianity. She viewed Christians as "judgmental, out of date and irrelevant to modern life" and was actively working to expose what she called the "frailties of the Religious Right." Then she met Jesus — through the kindness of a pastor who didn't preach at her, but invited her to dinner. Her conversion cost her everything: her career, her community, her identity, and her relationship. As she famously wrote: **"I lost everything but the dog."** Today, Rosario is a homeschooling mother of four adopted children, married to a Presbyterian pastor, and the author of several books including *The Secret Thoughts of an Unlikely Convert* and *Openness Unhindered*. Her testimony is one of the most powerful and unlikely conversions of our era — and it offers profound lessons for the Church. This episode is about what we can **learn** from her story — and how to **respond** with wisdom, grace, and discernment. --- ## 🔑 KEY LESSONS FROM ROSARIO'S TESTIMONY **1. The Bible has the right to interrogate us — not the other way around.** Rosario spent two years reading the Bible to refute it. She read it seven times. But *"the Bible got bigger inside me than I was."* She now testifies: *"The Bible knows you better than you know yourself."*【22†L5-L8】 **2. Repentance and belief go together.** Rosario warns against a "half-gospel" that offers forgiveness for guilt without the power to break the bondage of sin. *"There is only one thing to do when you meet the risen Jesus Christ. You fall on your face, and you repent of your sins."*【22†L5-L8】 **3. Hospitality is the most powerful apologetic.** Ken Smith didn't share the gospel with Rosario or invite her to church. He invited her to dinner. He told her: *"There's a difference between acceptance and approval. If you can live with that difference, I can live with that difference."*【22†L5-L8】 **4. Identity is found in Christ, not in feelings.** Rosario now states: *"Do you have lesbian neighbors? No. You have neighbors. These beloved image-bearers of a Holy God have fallen into lusts of the flesh... But they are not a different kind of man or woman."*【22†L5-L8】 **5. The Cross is the only hope.** Rosario now testifies: *"In saying yes to Jesus and no to the desires of my flesh, I learned that the only way to peace with my God was through the Cross; the one that Jesus died on and the one that I was called, with the help of Jesus, to carry."*【22†L5-L8】 **6. The Church must welcome radical testimonies.** Rosario faced rejection from both her former community and some Christians. The Church must do better — welcoming unlikely converts with open arms, not suspicion. **7. True conversion costs everything.** Rosario lost her career, her community, her identity, and her relationship. But she gained Christ — and that was worth it all. --- ## ⚖️ WHAT SHE DID vs. WHAT SCRIPTURE TEACHES vs. WHAT SHE COULD HAVE DONE | **Area** | **What Rosario Did** | **What Scripture Teaches** | **What She Could Have Done Differently** | **Supporting Scriptures** | |---|---|---|---|---| | **Identity Formation** | Defined her identity by her sexual feelings and desires — embraced the label "lesbian" as her core identity | Identity is given by God, not self-created. We are image-bearers first — our identity is found in Christ, not in our feelings | Sought her identity in Christ rather than in her sexuality. Recognized that feelings do not define who she is | *"God created man in his own image... male and female he created them"* (Genesis 1:27); *"If anyone is in Christ, he is a new creation"* (2 Corinthians 5:17); *"I have been crucified with Christ... it is no longer I who live, but Christ who lives in me"* (Galatians 2:20) | | **Responding to Biblical Truth** | Approached the Bible "with an agenda to tear it down" — tried to refute it rather than submit to it | The Bible is God-breathed and has the right to interrogate our hearts and lives | Approached Scripture with humility, allowing it to speak into her life rather than trying to deconstruct it | *"Every Scripture is God-breathed and profitable for teaching, for reproof, for correction"* (2 Timothy 3:16-17); *"The word of God is living and active, sharper than any two-edged sword"* (Hebrews 4:12); *"The foolishness of God is wiser than men"* (1 Corinthians 1:25) | | **Understanding Sin** | Believed she was "very wonderful, gay, and sinless... and in no real need of a Savior" | All have sinned and fall short of God's glory — sin is universal and requires a Savior | Recognized that her deepest problem was not her sexuality but her unbelief — and repented of both | *"All have sinned, and fall short of the glory of God"* (Romans 3:23); *"The wages of sin is death, but the free gift of God is eternal life"* (Romans 6:23); *"If we confess our sins, he is faithful and righteous to forgive us"* (1 John 1:9) | | **Pursuing Justice** | Devoted her life to political activism, believing she was fighting for justice and liberation | True justice is found in Christ alone — political activism cannot save or transform hearts | Recognized that only the Gospel can truly set people free — and used her voice to point people to Christ | *"The word of the cross is foolishness to those who are dying, but to us who are being saved it is the power of God"* (1 Corinthians 1:18); *"Seek first God's Kingdom and his righteousness"* (Matthew 6:33); *"The only way to peace with God was through the Cross"* (Rosario's testimony)【22†L5-L8】 | | **Responding to Christian Hospitality** | Was initially suspicious but eventually drawn in by the Smiths' kindness and consistency | Christians are called to welcome strangers and show hospitality — even to enemies | (This was done to her — but the Church should continue this model of radical hospitality) | *"Do not neglect to show hospitality to strangers"* (Hebrews 13:2); *"Love your enemies, do good to those who hate you"* (Luke 6:27); *"Accept one another, just as Christ also accepted us"* (Romans 15:7) | --- ## 🏠 AREAS OF LIFE THIS TESTIMONY AFFECTED **1. Spiritual Life** Rosario went from militant atheism and activism to **radical faith in Christ**. Her spiritual identity was completely transformed — from an enemy of the Cross to a daughter of the King. She describes her conversion as **"a mix of an alien abduction and a train wreck"** — a comprehensive chaos that led to new life.【22†L5-L8】 **2. Career & Finances** She walked away from a **tenured professorship at Syracuse University** — a position most academics spend their entire careers trying to achieve. She lost her academic reputation, her publishing career, and her professional identity. **3. Relationships & Community** She lost her lesbian partner, her LGBTQ+ community, and many of her activist friends. She also faced **rejection from some Christians** who doubted her testimony. She famously said: *"I lost everything but the dog."*【22†L5-L8】 **4. Mental & Emotional Health** Her conversion was not easy. She describes it as landing her into **"a complicated and comprehensive chaos."** She had to process the loss of everything she had built her life around — while simultaneously building a new identity in Christ.【22†L5-L8】 **5. Identity & Purpose** She went from being a prominent queer theorist and activist to being a **homemaker, homeschooling mother of four adopted children, and pastor's wife**. Her purpose shifted from deconstructing Christianity to building a family and pointing others to Christ. **6. Family & Upbringing** Rosario was raised in a home that did not provide a strong spiritual foundation. Her conversion led her to **adopt four children** and build the kind of family she never had — a family rooted in the Gospel. --- ## ⚠️ WARNINGS: TRAPS TO ANTICIPATE **1. The "Identity = Feelings" Trap** The world tells us that our feelings define who we are. Rosario's testimony proves that **feelings are not identity** — they are fallen desires that must be submitted to Christ. Don't let anyone tell you that your feelings are the truest thing about you. **2. The "Half-Gospel" Trap** Rosario warns against a gospel that offers forgiveness without transformation. *"Repentance and belief go together."* If you're preaching a gospel that doesn't demand turning from sin, you're not preaching the real Gospel.【22†L5-L8】 **3. The "Us vs. Them" Trap** Rosario teaches that Christians must *"always see people as people, not as a position or side of a debate to be defeated."* Don't treat LGBTQ+ individuals as enemies — they are image-bearers in need of the same grace you received.【22†L5-L8】 **4. The "Intellectual Pride" Trap** Rosario once viewed Christians as "intellectually impaired." She was proud of her academic credentials and her ability to deconstruct Christian arguments. Pride kept her from God for years. Don't let your education or intellect become a barrier to faith. **5. The "Persecution" Trap** Rosario faced rejection from **both** her former community and some Christians. If you leave a secular worldview for Christ, expect backlash. But don't let the suspicion of some believers discourage you — God sees your heart. **6. The "Comfortable Christianity" Trap** Rosario's conversion cost her everything. She lost her career, her community, and her identity. Following Christ is not comfortable — it demands everything. Don't settle for a Christianity that doesn't cost you anything. **7. The "Too Far Gone" Trap** If Jesus can save a tenured queer theory professor who despised Christians, **no one is beyond His reach.** Don't believe the lie that your past or someone else's past is too dark for God's grace. --- ## 💬 CLOSING REFLECTION Rosario Champagne Butterfield's testimony is a **wake-up call** to the Church: - **The world's counterfeit light is real** — and it's seductive. - **The Bible has the right to interrogate us** — not the other way around. - **True conversion costs everything** — but Christ is worth it all. - **The Church must show radical hospitality** — welcoming the unlikely with open arms. *"For I am not ashamed of the gospel, for it is the power of God for salvation to everyone who believes."* — Romans 1:16 Rosario found this freedom. She lost everything but the dog — but she gained Christ. And she now dedicates her life to warning others about the deceptions of this age and pointing them to the only one who can save. **Will you listen? Will you learn? Will you respond with discernment — and with love?** --- **Follow Rosario's ministry: @RosariaButterfield** **#FromCounterfeitLightToChrist #RosarioButterfield #UnlikelyConvert #Testimony #JesusSaves #QueerTheory #Discernment #GabPro #Christian #WakeUp**

View this post on Gab