Gaul Atreides (@gaulatreides)

It is possible to be both genuinely pro-White and jew-neutral. Unlikely, but possible. Theoretically, the way that would work is simple: having true pro-White sympathies would constantly lead you to policy preferences that clash with jews. At every stage of conflict with jews, you would simply barge ahead with your policy proposals and pro-White values, and give jews no quarter. They would scream bloody murder and accuse you of all sorts of calumnies, but you would remain unfazed because you are firm in your belief and your affinity for your people. You would reason that the jews, to whom you bear no ill will, should acquiesce or be shoved aside if they present too great a hurdle to your pro-White activism. Again, this is theoretical. In practice, a jew-neutral pro-White would find it difficult to avoid settling on anti-semitism as a working philosophy. But my thought experiment is designed to demonstrate that the existence, flourishing, and success of pro-Whiteness does not require anti-semitism as a precondition. That is the power of a positive identity. In contrast, a negative identity....one formulated around attacks by outgroups rather than by unshakeable love for one's ingroup....is susceptible to self-defeating blowback if there is a perception of insufficient hatred of the outgroup. If a pro-White does not express the required level of anti-semitism, avowed anti-semites are liable to disavow that pro-White person and even say he deserves his dispossession for failing to oppose jews with forthright conviction. The logic of this kind of negative identity worldview could conceivably end up at the betrayal and abandonment of a vast swath of one's people for the perceived sin of infidelity to the anti-semitic creed. Ie, "they deserve it". Ideally, a pro-White movement balances a positive and negative identity. Working together, White racial identity will reach heights greater than with each alone. The positive identity pro-Whites will become savvier about the nature of the threats facing their race, while the negative identity anti-semites will become more charitable toward the Whites whose values preclude their embrace of the darker philosophies.